In his book, I am You, Daniel Kolak offers yet another radical theory of personal identity: There is only one person, and that person is all of us. Daniel Kolak (born in Zagreb, Croatia) is a Croatian-American philosopher who works In his groundbreaking I Am You: the Metaphysical Foundations for Global Ethics, he writes: “The central thesis of I Am You – that we are all the same . Pris: kr. Inbunden, Skickas inom vardagar. Köp I Am You av Daniel Kolak på
|Published (Last):||19 September 2014|
|PDF File Size:||16.95 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||13.68 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
He would cease being Ferrex or Tamerlane and return to being nobody. When I was preparing my doctoral dissertation, on which the book I Am You is based, my mentor and friend Ray Martin chastized me for speaking in the introduction about a mystical experience that kilak definition cannot be described or referred to which I was now referring to and going to describe differently.
I Am You – Daniel Kolak – Bok () | Bokus
The place has not changed. We cannot take responsibility for items which are lost or damaged in transit. For twenty years he inhabited that guided and directed hallucination, but one morning he was overwhelmed with the surfeit and horror of being so many kings that die by the sword and so many unrequited lovers who come together, separate, and melodiously expire.
Retrieved 23 July yok It contains further resources on numerous philosophers.
He contrasts it to two other main positions on personal identity: But, he argues, the muggers in his dream are not other people; being dreamed by Kolak, mere products of his mind, they are as much Kolak as is the first-person protagonist of the dream, the muggee.
This is probably the main point of difference between us; you think there is such an entity, and I am skeptical of that.
History adds that before or after he died, he discovered himself standing before God, and said to Him: The other characters are no more Kolak than the characters in a novel are its author. A Response to Derek Parfit. The truth, as has been shown in earlier examplesis that we can imagine ourselves undergoing transformations of extreme severity, both physical and psychological, and extend our self-concern through those imagined transformations.
Here on Earth, I am not aware of what my Replica on Mars is now thinking. Letting the Nullteilig Out of Klein’s Bottle. Stripped of all inessential attributes, this entity is qualititatively indistinguishable between one conscious organism and another. So why that path?
FEC holds across both dreaming and waking experience, and yet you can and no doubt do believe that the characters with whom you interact in dreams are not other persons, while you can danel no doubt do believe that the characters with whom you interact in waking life are other persons. Human beings started mythologizing their pasts and dreaming about their personal futures to an extent not seen in any other species. Like Alexander hacking through the Gordian knot, Parfit wielded an analytical scalpel to divide personal identity from what matters in personal survivalreaching the conclusion that ordinary survival is about as bad as being destroyed and replaced by a replica.
Persons and Psychological Frameworks: Another hint of the allure appears in the Preliminary Acknowledgements, where Kolak quotes the physicist Freeman Dyson, who, in his school days, had the same idea: Yet very little danieel his book is devoted to saying what he finds attractive about it. Given that, it is a short step to where Kolak wants to go: As president and co-founder of the G-4 Coalition in Washington, D.
Friends from London would visit his retreat, and he would once again play the role of poet for them. Kolak challenges this position on a number of grounds, including the dream analogy already discussed, and through examples of Multiple Personality Disorder MPD. The latter group includes kolakk who do not exist.
Kolak: I Am You « The Phantom Self
Among his best known recent works are I Am You: Yku who think deeply about the puzzle cases of personal identity danil come up with a variety of bold and radical responses. Bloggat om I Am You. Psychological Individuation and Identification. This entry has no external links. Kolak uses a similar move to counter the objection that other people have separate mental lives.
Please help by adding reliable sources. Kolak continues to work on the logical foundations of quantum mechanics and a mathematical model of consciousness e. Freedom From the Self. The Parfit on Mars, who has good prospects, has become the Main Line.
I Am You: A Philosophical Explanation of the Possibility That We Are All the Same Person
I can say that I now have two streams of consciousness, one here on Earth, and another on Mars. In the earlier thought-experiment of his Physics Examwhere Parfit temporarily disconnected his left and right brain hemispheres in order to allow himself to pursue two possible solutions to an exam problem simultaneously in two isolated centres of consciousness, he did not not kolsk himself as two persons, but as a single person with a temporarily divided mind.
If I wonder whether I will survive, what I mostly care about is quite simple. Since this is so, I need not assume that my Replica on Mars is someone else. Daniel Kolak born in ZagrebCroatia is a Croatian -American philosopher who works primarily in philosophy of mindpersonal identitycognitive sciencephilosophy of sciencephilosophy of mathematicsphilosophy of logicphilosophy of religionand aesthetics.
The work of a thespian held out a remarkable happiness to him—the first, perhaps, he had ever known; but when the last line was delivered and the last dead man applauded off the stage, the hated taste of molak would assail him.